The Most Expensive ZIP Codes in Key West
Ranked from observed Zillow data as of August 2026 — not a forecast. 9 ZIP codes in the Key West, FL area. See the Key West forecast →
5 most expensive ZIP codes in Key West, FL are shown at larger size; all 14 ZIPs shown, colored by typical home value and sized by population. 6 have a full ZIP page (ringed in blue) — click one to view it.
Which are the best ZIP codes to buy in Key West?
There is no single answer, because "best" depends on what a buyer is optimizing for. The three tables below rank the same 9 ZIP codes three different ways: by typical home value, by how much prices have actually moved over the past year, and by how far a home's price stretches against observed rent. A ZIP code that leads one list rarely leads all three.
Most expensive — August 2026
Ranked by typical home value (Zillow ZHVI), highest first.
| # | ZIP | City | Typical value | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 33036 | Islamorada | $1,240,460 | |
| 2 | 33037 | Key Largo | $1,096,047 | |
| 3 | 33042 | Summerland Key | $1,028,593 | |
| 4 | 33040 | Key West | $949,386 | |
| 5 | 33070 | Islamorada | $917,023 |
Fastest-appreciating — past 12 months
Ranked by observed price change over the trailing year, not a forecast.
| # | ZIP | City | Typical value | 1-yr change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 33070 | Islamorada | $917,023 | +4.8% |
| 2 | 33037 | Key Largo | $1,096,047 | +3.5% |
| 3 | 33043 | Big Pine Key | $742,324 | +2.7% |
| 4 | 33036 | Islamorada | $1,240,460 | +2.6% |
| 5 | 33042 | Summerland Key | $1,028,593 | +2.1% |
Best rental value — past 12 months
Ranked by price-to-rent (typical value ÷ observed annual rent), lowest first. These are the ZIP codes where buying looks cheapest relative to renting.
| # | ZIP | City | Typical value | Price ÷ annual rent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 33042 | Summerland Key | $1,028,593 | 17× |
| 2 | 33040 | Key West | $949,386 | 22.7× |
| 3 | 33070 | Islamorada | $917,023 | 24.8× |
| 4 | 33037 | Key Largo | $1,096,047 | 27.6× |
Frequently asked questions
What is the most expensive ZIP code in the Key West area?
33036 (Islamorada), with a typical home value of $1,240,460 as of August 2026, the latest month Zillow has published.
Which are the best ZIP codes to buy in Key West?
It depends on the goal. This page ranks three separately: the most expensive ZIP codes (highest typical value), the fastest-appreciating (largest observed price gain over the past year), and the best rental value (lowest price relative to observed rent). The three lists often name different ZIP codes.
Is this page showing forecasts?
No. Every number on this page is observed Zillow data as of August 2026, not a forecast. Sialim's forecasts, at the metro level, are on the linked metro forecast page.
ZIP-level values shown here are observed Zillow data, not forecasts. Sialim's forecasting engine works at the metro level today; ZIP-level forecasts are planned for Sialim Pro. Data © Zillow, via Zillow Research.