53091 — Theresa, WI Home Values
Typical home value $357,917 as of June 2026 · 4th of 13 in Beaver Dam, WI
Blue: typical home value (Zillow ZHVI) in ZIP code 53091, June 2021 to June 2026. This page shows observed data only; no forecast.
How 53091 compares in the Beaver Dam, WI area
ZIP code 53091 (Theresa, WI) has a typical home value of $357,917 as of June 2026, ranking 4th of 13 ZIP codes tracked in the Beaver Dam, WI area, more expensive than about 77% of ZIP codes in the metro. Prices here have moved +7.1% over the trailing 12 months. Over the past five years, the typical value in this ZIP code has changed +34.9%, from $265,413 in June 2021 to $357,917 in June 2026.
Every figure above is observed Zillow data. Sialim's forecasting engine works at the metro level; see the Beaver Dam, WI forecast for a modeled outlook, or browse the full ranked list of ZIP codes in Beaver Dam.
Population and demographics
ZIP code 53091 has a population of 2,113, per the Census Bureau's American Community Survey 5-year estimate. By race and ethnicity: 92.3% White, 3.6% Hispanic or Latino, 3% Black or African American, 0.4% Asian, 0.4% two or more races, and 0.3% American Indian or Alaska Native.
Nearby public schools
| School | Address | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Theresa Elementary | 422 S Milwaukee St, Theresa, WI | 1.3 mi |
| Parkview Early Learning Center | 259 Oak St, Mayville, WI | 5.8 mi |
| Mayville Elementary | 445 N Henninger St, Mayville, WI | 6 mi |
Distance is straight-line from the ZIP code's center; driving distance will be longer. School attendance is set by district boundaries, not proximity. Confirm which school a specific address is zoned for with the local school district. Source: National Center for Education Statistics.
Frequently asked questions
What is the typical home value in ZIP code 53091?
$357,917 as of June 2026, the latest month Zillow has published observed data for.
Is 53091 an expensive ZIP code in the Beaver Dam, WI area?
53091 ranks 4th of 13 ZIP codes in the Beaver Dam, WI area by typical home value, more expensive than about 77% of ZIP codes in the metro.
How much have home values in 53091 changed over the past year?
+7.1% over the trailing 12 months, from observed Zillow data.
What is the population of ZIP code 53091?
2,113, per the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey 5-year estimate.
What are the closest public schools to ZIP code 53091?
Theresa Elementary (1.3 mi), Parkview Early Learning Center (5.8 mi), Mayville Elementary (6 mi), by straight-line distance from the ZIP code's center. School attendance is set by district boundaries, not proximity. Confirm assignment with the local school district.
Is this page showing a forecast for 53091?
No. Every number on this page is observed Zillow data as of June 2026, not a forecast. Sialim's forecasting engine runs at the metro level; see the Beaver Dam, WI forecast for a modeled outlook.
ZIP-level values shown here are observed Zillow data, not forecasts. Sialim's forecasting engine works at the metro level today; ZIP-level forecasts are planned for Sialim Pro. Data © Zillow, via Zillow Research.